Long-term tooth retention: diabetes, smoking and periodontal maintenance

Summarised from:

Tooth loss in periodontally compromised patients: Results 20 years after active periodontal therapy
(Journal of Clinical Periodontology; doi: 10.1111/jcpe.13010)

Authors:

Bernadette Pretzl, Shirin El Sayed, Dorothea Weber, Peter Eickholz, Amelie Bäumer

Summarised by:

Dr Varkha Rattu

Research Topic:

Background + Aims

  • Periodontal treatment aims to control inflammation and preserve natural teeth, including those with reduced supporting bone. Long-term follow-up helps establish whether these benefits persist and which patients may require additional support
  • This study aimed to:
    • Assess tooth loss over 20 years after active periodontal therapy and identify patient characteristics associated with poorer outcomes.

Materials + Methods

  • Long-term observational follow-up at Heidelberg University Hospital, Germany.
  • 70 of 100 patients previously examined at 10 years were re-examined approximately 20 years after treatment.
  • Active periodontal therapy (APT) involved cleaning below the gumline, with surgery or antibiotics where indicated.
  • Supportive periodontal therapy (SPT) included ongoing monitoring, oral-hygiene instruction, professional plaque removal and further treatment of affected sites.
  • Records and examinations established tooth loss during the first and second decades. Wisdom teeth were excluded.
  • Researchers assessed whether diabetes, heart disease, smoking, age and maintenance attendance were associated with tooth loss.
    • Diabetes status was recorded from medical history; the study did not report an analysis of HbA1c or glycaemic control.
  • Poisson regression (a statistical method for analysing event counts) examined associations between patient characteristics and the number of teeth lost.

Results

  • Patients had 1,639 teeth after APT. 201 were lost over 20 years, leaving approximately 88% retained.
    • Mean tooth loss was 2.87 teeth per patient, equivalent to 0.14 teeth per patient per year.
    • 27.1% lost no teeth, and 67.1% lost <4 teeth. Only 4.3% lost ≥10 more teeth.
  • Average tooth loss increased from 1.20 teeth in the first decade to 1.67 in the second.
  • Regular maintenance attendance was associated with a lower expected tooth-loss count: risk ratio (RR) 0.30 (95% CI 0.21–0.43).
  • Smoking was associated with a higher tooth-loss count: RR 4.17 (95% CI 2.59–6.71).
  • Older age, heart disease and being without a partner were also associated with greater tooth loss.
  • These are observational associations and do not establish direct causes.
  • Diabetes was statistically associated with tooth loss (RR: 0.26; p<0.001), but the direction requires caution

Limitations

  • The small sample and multiple predictors reduce confidence in the regression estimates.
  • 30 patients were unavailable at 20 years – their absence may make outcomes appear more favourable.
  • Tooth loss included extractions for any reason, rather than periodontal disease alone.
  • Maintenance received elsewhere and reasons for extraction were incompletely documented.
  • Diabetes findings require particular caution – the authors described an adverse association, but the regression table reports a RR <1
    • The reported number of participants with diabetes also differs between the text (n = 6) and table (n = 2), preventing a confident interpretation.
    • The limited number of patients with diabetes means there is lack of confidence in the finding.
  • These are observational associations and do not establish direct causes.

Conclusion

  • Substantial periodontal damage does not inevitably lead to extensive tooth loss – most teeth were retained over 2 decades in this treated cohort.
  • The findings support continued periodontal maintenance and attention to modifiable risks, particularly smoking, while recognising that individual outcomes vary and the diabetes-specific findings remain uncertain.
Read the full article Back to Research

Research  |  23.10.18

clock icon 5 mins to read

Share this page:

Copy Link

You might also like...

Events

Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub x #DiabetesChat

Hosted by #diabeteschat, join Dr Varkha Rattu and the team behind the Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub for an insightful discussion exploring the importance of managing periodontitis and diabetes.

Read more

Events

Oral Health Challenges Among People Living With Diabetes

Dr Antoniszczak will present a lecture about the oral health challenges among people living with diabetes. This lecture explores the key challenges faced by individuals living with diabetes, focusing on…

Read more

Events

Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub x #DiabetesChat

Hosted by #diabeteschat, join Dr Varkha Rattu and the team behind the Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub for an insightful discussion exploring the importance of managing periodontitis and diabetes.

Read more

Events

Oral Health Challenges Among People Living With Diabetes

Dr Antoniszczak will present a lecture about the oral health challenges among people living with diabetes. This lecture explores the key challenges faced by individuals living with diabetes, focusing on the relationship between diabetes and oral health.

Read more
icon1 services

Periodontitis is the 6th most prevalent condition globally

icon1 services

Periodontitis and diabetes are bidirectionally linked

icon1 services

Diabetic complications are increased if you have both diseases

icon1 services

Successful periodontal treatment can improve blood glucose control

icon1 services

Periodontitis is the 6th most prevalent condition globally

icon1 services

Periodontitis and diabetes are bidirectionally linked

icon1 services

Diabetic complications are increased if you have both diseases

icon1 services

Successful periodontal treatment can improve blood glucose control

Our Team

Team - The Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub

Dr Varkha Rattu

Founder & Periodontology Co-Lead

Team - The Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub

Dr Amar Puttanna

Diabetes Co-Lead

Team - The Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub

Dr Rajeev Raghavan

Diabetes Co-Lead

Team - The Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub

Professor Mark Ide

Periodontology Co-Lead

Team - The Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub

Professor Luigi Nibali

Periodontology Co-Lead

Team - The Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub

Dr Dominika Antoniszczak

Education & Support Advisor

Team - The Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub

Dr Jasmine Loke

Clinical Content Advisor

Team - The Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub

Dr Mira Shah

Patient Resource Advisor

Team - The Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub

Elaine Tilling

Outreach & Communications Lead

Team - The Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub

Dr Varkha Rattu

Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub Position: Founder & Periodontology Co-Lead

Team - The Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub

Dr Amar Puttanna

Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub Position: Diabetes Co-Lead

Team - The Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub

Dr Rajeev Raghavan

Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub Position: Diabetes Co-Lead

Team - The Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub

Professor Mark Ide

Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub Position: Periodontology Co-Lead

Team - The Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub

Professor Luigi Nibali

Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub Position: Periodontology Co-Lead

Team - The Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub

Dr Dominika Antoniszczak

Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub Position: Education and Support Advisor

Team - The Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub

Dr Jasmine Loke

Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub Position: Clinical Content Advisor

Team - The Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub

Dr Mira Shah

Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub Position: Patient Resource Advisor

Team - The Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub

Elaine Tilling

Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub Position: Outreach and Communications Lead

View All